Saturday, October 15, 2011

OA NOS.250/2011 TO 2532011, 255/2011 to 256/2011, 308/2011 AND 311/2011 TO 313/2011 --oral--on 06-09-2011

CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
BANGALORE BENCH, BANGALORE

ORIGINAL APPLICATIONS NOS.250/2011 TO 2532011, 255/2011 to
256/2011, 308/2011 AND 311/2011 TO 313/2011

TUESDAY, DATED THIS THE 6TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2011

HON'BLE SMT. LEENA MEHENDHALE ...MEMBER(A)
HON'BLE SHRI V. AJAY KUMAR ...MEMBER(J)


1. S.Ramesha,
Station Master,
Bidadi, Bangalore Division,
South Western Railway ...Applicant in OA No.250/2011

2. M.S.Babu,
Station Master,
Maddur, Bangalore Division,
South Western Railway ...Applicant in OA No.251/2011

3. A.G.Shivakumar,
Station Master,
Kengeri, Bangalore Division,
South Western Railway ...Applicant in OA No.252/2011

4. K.S.Thejashvi,
Station Master,
Mandya, Bangalore Division,
South Western Railway ...Applicant in OA No.253/2011

5. N.Sreekanthaiah,
Station Master,
Ramanagaram, Bangalore Division,
South Western Railway ...Applicant in OA No.255/2011

6. M.S.Prabhu,
Station Master,
Mandya, Bangalore Division,
South Western Railway ...Applicant in OA No.256/2011

7. M.S.Puttaswamy,
S/o M.K.Sivanna,
No.18, II Cross ISEC Road,
Nagarbhavi, Bangalore-72.
Station Master,
Dodbele, Bangalore Division,
South Western Railway ...Applicant in OA No.308/2011

8. A.S.Javaraya Gowda,
Station Master,
Bangaloare, Bangalore Division,
South Western Railway,
S/o Shankaraiah, Residing at
C/o Chikka Sidde Gowda,
8th Cross, Chamundiswari Nagar,
Mandya. ...Applicant in OA No.311/2011



- 2 -
9. V.Girish Karnada,
S/o T.Venkatesh,
33/A, 'Ananya Nilaya',
27th Ward, II Cross,
Rayaradoddi, Magadi Road,
Ramanagaram, Karnataka-52 159.
Station Master,
Baiyyappanahalli, Bangalore Division,
South Western Railway ...Applicant in OA No.312/2011

10. D.Dhananjaya,
C/o Mudde Gowda,
No.1589/A, Giridhama,
Chamundeswara Nagara,
10 Cross, Mandya, Karnataka,
Station Master,
Pandavapura, Bangalore Division,
South Western Railway ...Applicant in OA No.313/2011

(By Advocate M/s.Ratio Legis)
Vs.

1. Union of India,
rep. By General Manager,
South Western Railway,
Gadag Road, Hubli – 580 020.

2. The Divisional Railway Manager,
Bangalore Division,
South Western Railway,
Bangalore – 560 023.

3. The Senior Divisional Personnel Officer,
Bangalore Division,
South Western Railway,
Bangalore – 560 023.
....Respondents in OA Nos.250/2011 to 253/2011, 255/2011 to 256/2011 308/2011 & 311/2011 to 313/2011

O R D E R (ORAL)

HON'BLE SMT. LEENA MEHENDHALE ...MEMBER(A)

All these 10 OAs though filed separately, belonging to the employees of the same rank viz., Station Master and working under South Western Railways and impugned a similar order with the similar prayer, they are disposed of by a common order and the matrix of OA No.250/2011 at Sl. No.1 is used for sake of convenience.
2. The applicant is challenging Annexure-A/2 as impugned order. However, we find this is a consequence of an earlier order dated 24.1.2009 at Annexure-A/1, which informs the applicant about the reduction in his pay based on his
- 3 -
request for a transfer to the division of his choice. He has not challenged it since last 3 years. Hence OA is dismissed. The applicant will have the liberty to challenge Annexure-A/1, if he so desires and subject to the provision regarding delay.


(V.AJAY KUMAR) (LEENA MEHENDHALE)
MEMBER(J) MEMBER(A)
sd.

No comments:

Post a Comment